Due to the increased amount of troops that we are sending to Afghanistan and the complete lack of cultural understanding displayed within the MSM I decided to due a mini-series of articles on Afghanistan. The first couple will focus upon the ethnic groups and culture of Afghanistan. Tonight I am going to try to shed some light on the different ethnic groups within Afghanistan.
This is not a complete or scholarly work. This will be generalized in nature in order to keep it relatively short enough for a blog entry. There are entire books written upon the subject. One of my personal favorites right now is, "Koran, Kalashnikov, and Laptop" by Antonio Giustozzi. I highly recommend it. Not only does it hit on the major elements of the culture of Afghanistan but also the reasons and the way the Taliban have become resurgent within the country.
Their are five main ethnic groups within Afghanistan. They are the Pashtun, the Hazara, the Tajik, the Uzbeck, and the Nuristani. The Pashtun are the largest and inhabit in general the southern and eastern regions of the country. Their ethnic lands stretch across this region of Afghanistan and throughout the FATA and North-West Frontier Provinces in Pakistan. They have two main "super tribes" within them, called the Durrani and the Ghilzai. Historically they have been the ruling tribe of Afghanistan with such notable figures as King Durrani and President Karzai.
The Tajiks are next group. They are closely related to the Persians in Iran and to the people that inhabit the countries to the north of Afghanistan such as Tajikistan and Uzbekistan. They are well educated, and very good artisans. They generally inhabit the northern sector of Afghanistan with some areas within the eastern portion of the country.
The next group is the Uzbeks. They are ethnically a Turkmen people. They inhabit in general the north central and north western regions of the country. They again are well educated, superb craftsman, and generally enjoy ethnic ties to the people that live to the north of Afghanistan in Uzbekistan and Tajikistan.
The Hazaras are the next group, and generally believed to be descended from Genghis Khan's Army. They live in general within the central part of Afghanistan, but do have communities within the FATA and North-West Frontier Provinces of Pakistan. They are educated, great warriors, and farmers. One key thing that sets them apart from the other groups, is that in general they are Shiite Islam while the others are generally Sunni.
The last group is the Nuristani. They are much more lighter skinned then the other ethnic groups, and many have blond hair. They are considered to be ethnically close to both the Persians and the Indian People. They historically claim lineage to Alexander the Great's Army, and after seeing them and their features I tend to believe it. Again, they cherish education, skilled artisans, and fierce warriors.
A reoccurring trait that you see over and over again is the well educated, skilled artisan and craftsman, and fierce warriors. That is the God's honest truth. They are a proud people, and they have a right to be.
A pronounced difference historically between the Afghan People and Western People is their understanding of identity. If I walked down a street in America and asked what are you, a general answer would be American, or maybe I'm from Texas. That is not the way the Afghan's see things. They will first tell you their family unit, then maybe a larger family unit or clan, then a tribe or sub-tribe, then a tribe, then maybe I'm an Afghan. The focus is bi-polarly different from ours. As we have an identity based upon our country, they have an identity based from the bottom up. Their family, their clan, their tribe, and then their country are the most important things. Keep this in mind, it will become very important soon.
Warlords, the MSM loves to use that word. Many times these men are tribal leaders. Yes, some of them have done illegal things by our standards, and make careful note of that, by our standards. Growing poppy many times is not seen as a bad thing. Smuggling goods, is not seen as a bad thing if it helps your family and tribe prosper, and it is all you have. Now remember; family, tribe, clan, country is the order. Tribal Leaders will do what is necessary to help their Tribe. If they need money and poppy is the only way, well they will grow Poppy. Now I am not going to say they are all misunderstood. But, most of the problem is we don't understand them at all. Yes, some have done some very bad things. But, to make a generalized statement that Warlords are all bad, shows you do not understand the complete picture.
Finally for tonight, there is a reason why it is called the, "warring season." Families will fight other families. Clans will fight other clans. Tribes will fight other tribes. Super-Tribes will fight other super-tribes. It is a way of life that has gone on for a very long time. What does this all mean? They are fiercely independent. If they need something, whether that is security, stability, or money, they will find a way. If the central government is not providing it, they will find a way. If that means joining with the Taliban, for the time being, then that is what they will do. This is what GEN Petraeus and Secretary of Defense Gates are referring to as the Moderate Taliban that we need to engage. It is these people that we have to out-reach to and sway them back to our, "side."
But, it is only through Central and Local Government, Afghan National Army, and Afghan National Police penetration in these areas with viable alternatives to the Taliban that we will accomplish this. This is our (ISAF and Afganistan's) challenge over the next year and the next decade.
Tomorrow I will get into more on Koran, Kalashnikov, and Laptop and the Taliban.
God Bless America
Bryan
Sphere: Related Content